Connect with us

Sport

Our women’s teams still need more support

Published

on

As part of Women in Sport Week, Adam Moynihan reflects on the major issues affecting our female athletes today

Everyone loves a bandwagon. The success of the Irish women’s soccer team has done an awful lot for the visibility and popularity of women’s sport in this country, and both will likely slip into overdrive for the World Cup which gets underway in Australia in July.

We’re witnessing something similar here in Kerry with the ladies Gaelic football team. Last year’s surprise trip to the All-Ireland final captured the attention of a county that is obsessed with its men’s side. Kerry are currently top of Division 1 of the Ladies National League with a perfect record of five wins out of five. The run has people talking.

Of course, it shouldn’t necessarily take success to make people sit up and take notice. After all, female athletes train just as hard as the men and make the same sacrifices. But winning naturally piques public interest and it should hopefully be a springboard to more support and more appreciation down the line.

There are still issues that need to be discussed. Media coverage, or lack thereof, continues to irk participants and officials in the female ranks. As a journalist I have to hold my hands up here and admit that more needs to be done. We can be guilty at times of following the numbers but the reality is that for any sport to grow, it needs to be highlighted and promoted professionally and consistently.

That is something that I’m very happy to do and while we might not have the resources of larger, national papers, I absolutely appreciate that it’s important that we do our best.

I see it for myself when we share articles about Sarah Leahy or the Kerry ladies or St Paul’s or the Killarney RFC girls. The people I meet ask me about them and how they’re getting on. Even on that small local level, it generates interest, which can only be a good thing. 

In terms of professional sport, the question of equal pay continues to divide opinion. A sizeable portion of the sporting community seem to believe that pay should be commensurate to the revenue the sporting body in question is generating. Obviously organisations can’t pay out money that simply isn’t there yet but when men’s and women’s teams and athletes are under the one umbrella, equal pay should be a realistic target.

In the case of the GAA, the LGFA and the Camogie Association, there is no question that the men are being looked after far better than the women are, but this can’t be used as a stick to beat the GAA with. They are separate entities. When the proposed merger happens, you would hope to see a more level playing field in terms of expenses.

Trans inclusion is a hot button topic at the moment (particularly in light of the LGFA’s new policy) and it’s a conversation that stirs up strong emotions on both sides. There are, I think, legitimate arguments to be made both for and against but we must be wary of misinformation. This suggestion that boys and men are suddenly going to “decide” to be women and turn up to football or camogie training so they can dominate is, frankly, nonsense.

Trans players who wish to play will need to provide medical confirmation that they are transitioning if they are under 16 and proof that their testosterone levels are less than or equal to 10 nanomoles per litre if they are 16 or over. Anyone who thinks that boys and men are going to lie to their doctors and/or go through hormone therapy and/or try to trick the LGFA just to play football or camogie with women, is not living in the real world at all.

It’s interesting to note (and the survey that we carried out this week backs it up) that opposition to trans inclusion in women’s sport is far more fervent amongst men than it is amongst women. Ruminate on that for a minute.

There are things that need to be ironed out across the board but, all in all, there are lots of reasons to be optimistic about the future of women’s sport both locally and nationally.

If supporting your local women’s teams isn’t something that you’d normally do, there has never been a better time to start. There’s plenty of room on the bandwagon.

Advertisement

Sport

Kerry Camogie vow to back players in shorts/skorts controversy

Published

on

by Adam Moynihan

The Kerry County Board will back their players if they decide to defy the rulebook and wear shorts after officials at the Camogie Association’s National Congress voted to keep the controversial skort.

Speaking to the Killarney Advertiser, Kerry Camogie chairperson Ann Marie Russell confirmed that she is fully behind the players, the vast majority of whom want the skort to be binned.

“I know there have been calls for a protest, that they would all go out the first weekend of the championship and wear shorts,” Russell said. “If the players felt that was something they wanted to do, Kerry Camogie would absolutely support them.

“It should be up to the people who it affects. It doesn’t matter to me what the players wear or what they look like. They should be comfortable.”

The punishment for not wearing the correct playing gear is a yellow card which can be followed by a red card for dissent if not rectified.

Players say the skirt-like garment is not comfortable and they were hopeful that it would finally become a thing of the past when the issue was raised at Congress in Kildare last weekend.

However, a motion by Tipperary and Kerry to replace it with shorts was defeated by 64% to 36%. A similar proposal by Great Britain and Meath which would have given players the option to choose between skorts and shorts also fell well short of the two-thirds majority required (55% against, 45% in favour).

Voting was carried out by delegates from the various county boards as well as members of central and provincial councils. The majority of voters were female.

As one of Kerry’s two delegates, Russell confirmed that she voted in line with the players’ wishes, but she fears that delegates from some counties didn’t do likewise.

“Our job as delegates is to speak on behalf of the players and I definitely felt as though that wasn’t reflected by some of the other counties. I don’t know any girl in any age group at any level that goes to training in a skort. That, in itself, should speak volumes to the powers that be. Even the counties that wanted to keep the skorts, there’s no way their girls go training in skorts. I know they don’t.

“When camogie first started, women weren’t allowed to wear pants, so they had no choice but to wear skirts. They were longer at the time and things have evolved since then. The design is better. But there is a misconception that there are shorts underneath the skirts so ‘what’s the big deal?’ They’re not shorts, they’re compression shorts. That’s not the same thing.

“And look, I’m not wearing the skorts so it doesn’t matter to me. You have to listen to the players. That’s what I feel.

“We’re making decisions that really have little relevance to us, so we really have to take our players’ opinions into it. I’m not sure how many delegates go back and ask their players about these motions before they vote on them.”

Also speaking to the Killarney Advertiser, Kerry senior player Niamh Leen outlined the specific issues players have with the skort.

“If you went around the country, I guarantee you that you’d only find a handful of girls actually training in a skort,” the Clanmaurice woman said. “I’ve never been to a training session where someone was wearing a skort. We’re all in shorts.

“The practical side of it is that they’re really uncomfortable. They’re constantly rising up and I spend the majority of the match pulling the skort down instead of concentrating on the game. It shouldn’t be that way.”

According to Leen, the discomfort felt by players is not just physical. There is also a psychological discomfort involved.

“I am very paranoid about the skort, especially the length. You spend a lot of time bending over to pick up the ball and I am conscious of it. Even if you size up, it’s still too short. The only way to counteract it is to wear Skins (base layer) underneath which I don’t really like doing because that’s not overly comfortable either.

“It should be a players’ vote at the end of the day. We’re the ones who actually have to wear them and we should be the ones having the say. But, unfortunately, it’s not up to us.

“It’s very, very annoying. I could use harsher words but it is just frustrating, you know? We’ve wanted this motion to be passed for so many years.

“Nobody I know likes playing in a skort and it’s frustrating that our own organisation aren’t taking the players into account.”

This is not the first time a proposal to replace the skort has been rejected and players will have to wait another three years for the next Congress to try to alter the rules on an official basis.

Leen believes that she and her colleagues should not have to wait that long and questions the reasoning of those delegates who voted to keep the status quo.

“Honestly, I think it’s to keep the tradition and to keep us unique, and maybe they see the skorts as being more feminine, which is just mind-boggling for me. I just don’t understand how that could be a reason to keep something that’s making girls uncomfortable.

“I understand that it’s the tradition, but sometimes traditions have to move on.”

Attachments

Continue Reading

Sport

MATCH PREVIEW: Kerry name strong team for league final showdown with Armagh

Published

on

by Adam Moynihan

Lidl National League Division 1 Final

Kerry v Armagh

Sunday 3pm

Croke Park

Live on TG4

The Kerry ladies return to Croke Park on Sunday hoping to retain their Division 1 crown and managers Declan Quill and Darragh Long have named a strong-looking line-up for their battle against Armagh.

Kerry mostly used the league for experimenting but they still managed to win five of their seven matches, enough to secure a top two finish.

Now almost all of The Kingdom’s big hitters are back in play, as evidenced by the team they have selected for this weekend’s Division 1 decider at HQ.

Eleven members of the side that lost to Dublin in last year’s All-Ireland final have been selected to start against Armagh. The four “new” starters are goalkeeper Mary Ellen Bolger, full back Deirdre Kearney, midfielder Mary O’Connell and full forward Emma Dineen.

Dineen has rejoined the panel following a spell abroad and has slotted seamlessly into Kerry’s full forward line. She will be flanked by Footballer of the Year Louise Ní Mhuircheartaigh and the skilful Hannah O’Donoghue, who scored 1-2 against Galway a fortnight ago.

The only really notable absentee – apart from veterans like Emma Costello and Louise Galvin who haven’t yet featured for the team in 2024 – is Síofra O’Shea. The dynamic attacker, who heroically came off the bench in last year’s All-Ireland despite damaging her ACL in the lead-up to the game, is still rehabbing that serious injury.

Meanwhile, the return of All-Star defender Cáit Lynch bolsters Kerry’s back six. The Castleisland Desmonds woman has been used sparingly so far this year and she came on at half-time in that final regulation league game versus Galway.

Quill and Long are likely to call on substitutes Amy Harrington and Danielle O’Leary to make an impact if and when required.

Kerry’s sole loss in the league came at the hands of their final opponents, Armagh, who are looking to emulate what The Kingdom achieved last season by winning Division 1 at the first attempt after gaining promotion from Division 2 the previous season.

The Orchard County beat Kerry by 3-14 to 1-13 at the Athletic Grounds just over a month ago.

They flew through the regular phase of the 2024 competition, winning six games in a row before losing to Dublin in Round 7 with many key players being rested.

Star forward Aimee Mackin has been in blistering form. She has racked up 6-21 (4-15 from play) to date, including 2-6 (1-6 from play) in that meeting between the eventual finalists in March.

Armagh had not yet named their team for the final as this article was being published.

This match forms part of a double header with the Division 2 final between Kildare and Tyrone (1pm). Both games will be televised live on TG4.

Kerry team to play Armagh:

1. Mary Ellen Bolger (Southern Gaels)

2. Cáit Lynch (Castleisland Desmonds)

3. Deirdre Kearney (Na Gaeil)

4. Eilís Lynch (Castleisland Desmonds)

5. Aishling O’Connell (Scartaglin)

6. Ciara Murphy (MKL Gaels)

7. Kayleigh Cronin (Dr Crokes)

8. Mary O’Connell (Na Gaeil)

9. Anna Galvin (Southern Gaels)

10. Niamh Carmody (Captain – Finuge/St Senan’s)

11. Niamh Ní Chonchúir (Corca Dhuibhne)

12. Lorraine Scanlon (Castleisland Desmonds)

13. Hannah O’Donoghue (Beaufort)

14. Emma Dineen (Glenflesk)

15. Louise Ní Mhuircheartaigh (Corca Dhuibhne)

Subs: Ciara Butler, Danielle O’Leary, Amy Harrington, Ciara McCarthy, Ciara O’Brien, Katie Brosnan, Aoife Dillane, Bríd O’Connor, Kate O’Sullivan, Eilís O’Connor, Fay O’Donoghue, Jess Gill, Róisín Smith, Siobhán Burns, Keri-Ann Hanrahan.

Follow Adam on Twitter/X for all the latest updates from the Ladies Division 1 final at Croke Park

Attachments

  • (846 kB)
Continue Reading